Skip to content

Call For An Instant Quote - 01383 729053


OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline Discuss:

Are HMRC's Fines Legal Or Not?

Do HMRC Really Have The Right To Fine Taxpayers?
This Exclusive Examines The Issue.

Are HMRC's Fines Legal?

Accounting Question

OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline have discovered that The Chartered Institute of Taxation are saying that simply failing to keep records to an adequate standard does not, in its view, constitute sufficient grounds for firms to be fined by HMRCs BRC (Business Records Compliance) officers.

OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline discovered that Andrew Gotch, chairman of the CIOTs Owner-Managed Business sub-committee also supported this view. OnTax Accountant In Dunfermlineobserved that it is hard to see a legitimate basis for charging a penalty until it is demonstrated that the return is wrong for a record-based reason.

The tax man has agreed to operate a better reasonable tariff under the BRC where penalties of up to £3,000 are possible the advisor is doubtful though whether HMRC has the power to issue in-year penalties.

OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline has learned that the CIOT explained to them that they thought, a penalty (under BRC) could and must only be conceived once it has been proved beyond reasonable doubt that the bookkeeping records cannot support the given return. Therefore these penalties need to be linked to an incorrect return. Many leading experts from around the world debated on this issue and came up with the suitable policy changes and recommendations.

Yes! HMRCs Penalities Are Seriously In Doubt!

Blog Answer

Under this current BRC authority, the penalty rate for organizations are found to have poor records and no one has taken any improvement actions. OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline observed that since HMRC initially found those businesses to be inadequate, it offered its support to them. OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline discovered that HMRC offered the usual £500, or £250 if it is their first trading year and a little more for the following years. These penalties have to be paid in time to avoid legal problems.

Pay Penalties On Time!

Blog Advice

Also, according to HMRC, the maximum fine of £3,000 may be charged where the BRC officers find the organizations to have deliberately destroyed records during the check, although it may be only £1,500 if only some records are destroyed.

OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline believes that such steps can also help to punish such people and encourage everyone to pay their penalties on time if it applies to them, otherwise higher penalties will have to be paid. OnTax Accountant In Dunfermline suggests that you should pay your penalties on time. The tax money you pay goes into building a nation; so think about it. Become a regular taxpayer and enjoy the benefits!

Scroll To Top